Search    RealCorporateLawyer  Web by

return to FAQs

Direct Stock Purchase Plans


A. Understanding Direct Stock Purchase Plans and DRIPs
  • What is a "DRIP"?
  • What is a direct stock purchase plan?
  • What is a company-sponsored DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?
  • What is a bank-sponsored DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?
  • Why are direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs so popular with investors?
  • What are the disadvantages of direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs for investors?
  • How can direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs benefit a company?
B. Unregistered Direct Stock Purchase Plans and DRIPs on the Web
  • Does a company need to register the stock issued in its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?
  • If a company does not want to register the stock offered in its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan, what can it disclose about the plan on its Web site?
  • Can a third party host a Web directory?
  • Can a third party set up a Web site to offer DRIPs and direct stock purchase plans without having to register as a broker?
  • Can a third party maintain a Web directory of companies whose stock is offered through DRIPs and direct stock purchase plans without registering the stock?
  • How does the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act affect how banks administer direct stock purchase plans?
C. Impact of Online DRIPs and Direct Stock Purchase Plans
  • How have Web directories fueled direct stock purchase plan growth?
  • How have Web directories fueled DRIP growth?
  • What are the differences between online direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs?
  • Can a company register its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan and market it on the Web?
  • How are direct stock purchase plans growing?
  • How much does it cost an investor to participate in a DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?
  • How can investors determine which companies have DRIPs or direct stock purchase plans?
D. Understanding Synthetic DRIPs
  • Can investors reinvest dividends even if the company does not have a DRIP?
  • What is a "synthetic DRIP"?
  • How much do synthetic DRIPs cost?
  • Why do investors buy synthetic DRIPs if they are expensive?
  • Who offers synthetic DRIPs?



A. Understanding Direct Stock Purchase Plans and DRIPs

What is a "DRIP"?

A "dividend reinvestment plan." Investors can have their dividends automatically reinvested in a company's stock through these plans - as well as buy additional shares directly from a company without paying a commission.

DRIPs don't provide a way for an investor to buy that first share of stock that makes them eligible to participate in the DRIP. See more @ which companies have adopted DRIPs.

There are now ways to invest in what essentially are DRIPs without a company's involvement at all. See more @ synthetic DRIPs.

 

What is a direct stock purchase plan?

Very similar to a DRIP - except an investor can enroll and buy stock in a company without already being a stockholder. They also are known as "open market purchase plans" or "DRSPPs."

Larger companies with a liquid market for its stock tend to have direct stock purchase plans. See more @ which companies have adopted direct stock purchase plans.

Note that direct stock purchase plans differ from employee stock purchase plans - because only employees can participate in employee stock purchase plans, whereas any investor can participate in a direct stock purchase plan.

There are now ways to invest in what essentially are direct stock purchase plans without a company's involvement at all. See more @ synthetic DRIPs.

 

What is a company-sponsored DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?

A plan adopted and operated by the issuer. In these plans, stock is registered in an investor's name, not in "street name." See more @ street name ownership.

When an investor sells the stock, the company normally buys it back through the plan - although some plans require investors to sell their stock in the open market.

 

What is a bank-sponsored DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?

A plan adopted by the issuer - but operated by a bank. An investor pays an administrative fee to buy stock through its bank - the bank then buys the stock in the open market in the investor's name.

 

Why are direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs so popular with investors?

Because investors can routinely purchase a small amount of stock on a monthly basis - this is part of the popular "dollar cost averaging" investing strategy. It also allows investors to buy fractional shares of stock that otherwise would be too expensive for them to purchase.

Typical plan features include:

  • Requirement of an initial minimum investment of $200-250 and subsequent purchases of at least $50 a month,
  • Limitation on the number of shares that investors can buy (including an annual cap on the aggregate number of shares), and
  • Optional automatic investment via an electronic funds transfer from an investor's bank.
Investors benefit by not paying broker commissions. However, many companies charge administrative fees - which may be lower than broker's commissions, particularly since commission rates have dropped dramatically over the past few years.

 

What are the disadvantages of direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs for investors?

Investors can't dictate the stock prices at which they buy stock in these plans - since trades are made on a regular, periodic basis.

Many companies charge fees for their plans - so they may not be cost-effective, particularly since broker commission rates have dropped dramatically over the past few years.

 

How can direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs benefit a company?

Companies benefit from the ability to cross-market their products and services - and raise capital inexpensively.

They also benefit because the type of investors that invest in these plans tend to stay for the long term - and companies know the identity of these investors since they normally are record holders (which in turn facilitates the ability to electronically communicate). See more @ communicating with record holders.

Since individual investors buy through these plans - a company reduces its risk of losing control when it sells stock through its plan.

Back to TOC




B. Unregistered Direct Stock Purchase Plans and DRIPs on the Web

Does a company need to register the stock issued in its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?

No - so long as certain conditions are met. The SEC has an "issuer involvement" framework under which the SEC has outlined the roles for a company and an unaffiliated entity that sponsors the company's unregistered plan.

The SEC's "issuer involvement" framework has three factors:

  • how involved the company is in administering, operating and marketing the plan,
  • whether the plan is sponsored by - and offered through - an unaffiliated broker or bank (or other third party), and
  • whether the shares are purchased in the open market.
As reflected by these factors, if the company's involvement is ministerial so that buying through the plan basically is the same as buying from a broker - the stock doesn't need to be registered with the SEC. In other words, a company's role essentially is limited to administrative duties, paying the plan sponsor and the sponsor's broker commissions, and making payroll deductions.

A company can't solicit employees or investors to participate in an unregistered plan - only the plan sponsor can solicit these persons.

Source: The SEC set forth the parameters of when stock in these plans are not required to be registered in Releases 33-4790 (July 13, 1965); 33-6188 (February 1, 1980); and 33-6281 (January 15, 1981) as well as the no-action letter, Bank-Sponsored Investor Services Programs (available September 14, 1995).

 

If a company does not want to register the stock offered in its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan, what can it disclose about the plan on its Web site?

Only an announcement of the DRIP's availability - and the phone number of the independent agent from whom more information can be obtained. A company may not use its Web site to advertise the DRIP or its benefits.

The company's Web site can link to its independent agent's Web site, which has a DRIP brochure and enrollment card. However, it is important that the link may not go directly to the DRIP materials - it can only link directly to the agent's home page (from which investors can then use links to access the DRIP materials).

Source: The SEC provided this guidance in Example 2 of Release 33-7288 (May 9, 1996). The SEC staff basically reaffirmed this Example in the no-action letters issued to Securities Transfer Association, Inc. (available October 10, 1997) and Prodigy Services Corp. and Electronic Wall Street, Inc. (available May 9, 1998).

 

Can a third party host a Web directory?

Yes. In fact, most of the Web directories are hosted by third parties - they are not hosted by companies or the agents that typically sponsor plans. See more @ who hosts Web directories for plans.

Source: In a no-action letter Prodigy Services Corp. and Electronic Wall Street, Inc. (available May 9, 1998), the SEC staff allowed an Internet service provider to list unregistered plans sponsored by banks.

 

Can a third party set up a Web site to offer DRIPs and direct stock purchase plans without having to register as a broker?

So long as their activities are somewhat limited - and clearly fit within the guidance provided in the existing line of SEC staff no-action letters.

Third parties can post Web prospectuses and tombstone ads - as well as process orders from investors, including electronic payments. These orders and payments can be provided directly to a company's transfer agent.

However, if a third parties conducts too much "broker-like" activity for a plan, such as communicating about the nature of the transactions - it should register as a broker.

Note that banks are able to sponsor plans and not register as brokers - banks and transfer agents can't rely on this exemption.

Source: Banks are exempt from the definition of "broker" in Section 3(a)(4) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and company employees only have a limited exclusion from broker registration through a series of no-action letters. The SEC staff gradually has allowed more third-party online activity, as reflected in the two StockPower Inc. no-action letters (available November 3, 1998 and July 24, 1998). The last StockPower no-action letter clarified that tombstone ads on a Web site are not considered "special selling efforts" under Rule 102 of Regulation M.

 

Can a third party maintain a Web directory of companies whose stock is offered through DRIPs and direct stock purchase plans without registering the stock?

Yes - so long as the directories do not put investors in contact with the companies listed in the directory or accept fees from these companies.

The Web directories can only deal with plan administrators (typically the company's bank or transfer agent) to obtain:

  • their consents to have the plans included in the directory,
  • to execute contracts for posting the materials, and
  • to have any fees paid.
Web directories are not permitted to contact the companies themselves about these - or any other - activities.

As with unregistered plans in the paper world, companies may not receive any payments related to the stock sold and plan administrators must buy stock in the open market - they can't buy stock from the companies directly. See more @ who hosts Web directories for plans.

Source: The SEC staff provided this guidance in Prodigy Services Corp. and Electronic Wall Street, Inc. (available March 9, 1998).

 

How does the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act affect how banks administer direct stock purchase plans?

The statute establishes a new framework for determining what type of nonbanking activities are permissible for bank holding companies, including administration of these plans.

Banks that administer direct stock purchase plans still are able to administer these plans if:

  • they do not solicit transactions or provide investment advice regarding the purchase or sale of securities in these plans (but they can deliver SEC documents to plan participants),
  • they cannot net plan participants' purchases and sales - except for odd-lot programs or for registered plans, and
  • they have to place trades through a broker - which is permitted to be an affiliate of the bank.
Source: The Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act is available on the Senate Banking Committee's Web site at www.senate.gov/~banking/conf/.

Back to TOC



C. Impact of Online DRIPs and Direct Stock Purchase Plans

How have Web directories fueled direct stock purchase plan growth?

Before Web directories, an investor had to determine which public companies offered direct stock purchase plans - and then call each company (or its broker or bank agent) individually to inquire about the terms of its plan and ask for enrollment information.

From a Web directory, an investor can easily find out which companies have such plans - and even use electronic forms to enroll (but telephonic enrollment is not available yet). See more @ Web directories. Companies have found that Web directories have raised the profile of their plans and have dramatically increased investor participation.

 

How have Web directories fueled DRIP growth?

Not as much as direct stock purchase plans. However, the number of companies with DRIPs has steadily grown over the last decade - and investors can become better educated about DRIP investing due to a wealth of research information available online. See more @ where to find online DRIP information.

 

What are the differences between online direct stock purchase plans and DRIPs?

Although many public companies are posting announcements of their DRIPs on their Web site - few are posting prospectuses and none are allowing investors to enroll online from their Web sites.

In fact, for bank-sponsored plans, companies are limited to tombstone ad descriptions of their plans - with a link to more information on the bank's Web site. See more @ what is allowed online for a bank-sponsored plan.

Many more companies are willing to post Web prospectuses and allow investors to enroll online for direct stock purchase plans compared to DRIPs.




Can a company register its DRIP or direct stock purchase plan and market it on the Web?

Sort of - the marketing activity has to be limited to tombstone ad type content (and there are additional limits if the company is otherwise raising capital).

A company is limited to posting a brief summary of the plan, a plan prospectus and an application to enroll in the plan on its Web site - links to the company's investor relations Web page also is permitted. Any further marketing efforts beyond this must be limited to what is permitted for tombstone ads. See more @ what is permitted for tombstone ads.

If a company is raising capital, its plan isn't permitted to repurchase securities in the market if the company's stock price is a factor in pricing the repurchase. However, the SEC staff has stated that tombstone ads regarding a plan are permitted to be - or remain - posted even if a company is raising capital.

Note that companies can register their direct stock purchase plans on Form S-3 - so long as they have at least $75 million in market capitalization (held by non-control persons). Companies with smaller market capitalizations may be eligible to use Form S-3 to register stock for their DRIPs.

Source: The SEC staff addressed the requirements of registered plans in the no-action letter, First Chicago Trust Company of New York (available December 2, 1994). The SEC staff gradually has allowed more third-party online activity for registered plans, as reflected in the two StockPower Inc. no-action letters (available July 24, 1998 and November 3, 1998). The last letter clarified that tombstone ads on a Web site are not considered "special selling efforts" under Rule 102 of Regulation M.

 

How are direct stock purchase plans growing?

Although they have existed for decades, direct stock purchase plans have experienced phenomenal growth during the past few years - mainly due to the ability of investors to check online directories to determine which companies have plans as well as the ability for investors to easily obtain enrollment information online.

Compared to a handful in 1994, now more than 1500 public companies offer these plans. Only a relatively small percentage of these companies allow for online enrollment in a plan - the vast majority allow an enrollment form to be printed off and returned via postal mail.

 

How much does it cost an investor to participate in a DRIP or direct stock purchase plan?

Typically ranges between $1 to $5 per transaction, depending how frequently an investor buys stock through the plan (and it may cost more to sell than to buy).

There also may be an annual plan fee - as well as fees to move in and out of a plan (to discourage active trading).

 

How can investors determine which companies have DRIPs or direct stock purchase plans?

There are a number of online directories of companies that have such plans, including:

  • Netstock Direct (www.netstockdirect.com) - Since 1996, Netstock Direct has offered the most comprehensive Web site devoted to providing information about DRSPPs, with a searchable database of over 1300 companies that offer such plans. An advanced search engine allows searches to be based on specific investment criteria (such as industry or stock exchange), or according to plan features (like IRA options or automatic debits from a bank account). To help investors conduct research, Netstock Direct provides company profiles, plan summaries (including fees and requirements), and prospectuses or request forms to receive plan materials by postal mail. For some companies, the Enrollment Wizard assists an investor to enroll online in a plan, including having funds electronically transferred from a bank account.
  • Moneypaper (www.moneypaper.com) - Operated by a popular long-standing investment newsletter, The Moneypaper's Web site (specializes in DRIPs and contains a wealth of free educational content (including a "Kids Corner" to help children learn about investing!). It also has subscription-based content to help investors evaluate investment alternatives. For example, its INVEST% feature uses a mathematical formula designed to help investors obtain better results than they can from simple dollar-cost averaging. DirectInvesting.com (www.directinvesting.com) is also run by Moneypaper and assists investors to obtain the initial share required to invest through a DRIP and open DRIP accounts. Moneypaper also operates giftsofstock.com, which offers DRIP enrollment as a gift.
  • StockPower (www.stockpower.com) - recently tossed in the towel and went out of busines, StockPower's business model was to allow companies to offer stock through a DRSPP hosted on their own corporate Web sites, rather than relying on a Web plan directory site. About a dozen companies had used StockPower's turnkey proprietary service. Companies paid StockPower an annual fee based on the number of investors that invest in their DRSPPs using StockPower's service.
  • First Share (www.firstshare.com) - First Share is a unique referral program under which investors sell stock directly among themselves, mainly to obtain one share to become eligible to participate in a DRIP. First Share maintains a database of investors who desire to sell stock of companies that have DRIPs. When an investor wants to buy stock displayed on the Web site, First Share refers the request to a potential seller and delivers confirmations, but does not act as a broker.
  • Chase Mellon (www.cmssonline.com) - For DRIPs, these transfer agents post a list of the numerous companies whose plans they administer and phone numbers to order prospectuses and enrollment forms. For DRSPPs, all plan summaries are available online as well as some enrollment forms.
  • Drip Central (www.dripcentral.com) - Drip Central functions as a portal for DRIP information with a particular focus on education. It includes a complete online book, numerous articles and tutorials, and sponsors message boards for DRIP discussions.
  • National Association Investors Corporation (www.better-investing.org) - NAIC is a non-profit organization that has established the Low Cost Investment Plan as a way for investors to regularly, inexpensively buy stock. Although investors cannot buy stock online, the NAIC's Web site explains in detail how its plan works.
Investors also can ask a company's transfer agent or investor relations department if the company has a DRIP or direct stock purchase plan.

Back to TOC



D. Understanding Synthetic DRIPs

Can investors reinvest dividends even if the company does not have a DRIP?

Most likely. A number of brokers artificially create synthetic DRIPs to reinvest dividends of any public company paying cash dividends - regardless if that company actually has a DRIP. See more @ what is a "synthetic DRIP."

 

What is a "synthetic DRIP"?

A plan that allows investors to sign up for one online account and then invest regularly in multiple companies (including those that don't have DRIPs or direct stock purchase plans).

These plans offer investors the opportunity to regularly invest in fractionalized shares of almost any company - even companies that have not adopted a DRSPP or DRIP. In other words, these plans have no direct relation with the companies whose equity they offer. The brokers simply buy the stock in the open market.

Although commonly called "synthetic DRIPs," they sometimes are called "pseudo-DRIPs." Despite these names, these plans are more like a direct stock purchase plan than a DRIP.

The brokers that sponsor these plans do charge a fee - and some fees are relatively large. See more @ how much synthetic DRIPs cost. However, investors can conveniently enroll in only one plan - rather than having to enroll in a plan for each company whose stock it wants to buy.

 

How much do synthetic DRIPs cost?

Compared to traditional low-fee DRIPs, synthetic DRIPs can be expensive - and are not appropriate for investors who want to spread just a few hundred dollars over more than a few companies. Even a $2 fee is not cost effective for a $50 investment - because it constitutes 4% of the investment.

Most brokers offering synthetic DRIPs charge between:

  • $2-3 per monthly transaction,
  • $1-2 for custodial accounts, and
  • $5-10 for one-time only orders.

 

Why do investors buy synthetic DRIPs if they are expensive?

Synthetic DRIPs have become popular for investors seeking to buy stock in companies that do not have DRSPPs or DRIPs - and it's a way for an investor to conveniently enroll in only one plan, rather than having to enroll in a plan for each company whose stock it wants to buy.

Since most technology companies do not offer their own plans, online investors have flocked to brokers that offer these services - since it enables them to regularly purchase fractional shares in highly volatile technology stocks through the popular "dollar cost averaging" investment strategy.

 

Who offers synthetic DRIPs?

Several brokers, including:

  • Netstock Corporation now has a companion Web site called ShareBuilder (www.sharebuilder.com) to offer synthetic DRIPs. ShareBuilder allows investors to choose among more than 4000 companies and index funds, charging $2 each time an investor buys under its monthly investing program (only $1 for custodial accounts, and $5 for one-time only orders). The site also allows investors to make real-time trades for $19.95. As with Netstock's direct investing Web site, an account application is entirely electronic and fully secure.
  • Moneypaper presently is developing a Web site for Universal Stock Access accounts (www.usa-account.com), which are synthetic DRIPs. Through this Web site, investors will be able to enroll in synthetic DRIPs and traditional DRIP accounts as well as keep track of both types of investments. It is expected that the fees for synthetic DRIPs will be $2 per transaction or a flat annual fee of $199 for customers that invest in 10 or more companies monthly.
  • BuyandHold (www.buyandhold.com), which caters to investors with a long-term investment philosophy, is a recent entrant to the synthetic DRIP market through its E-ZVest service. Its "Set Your Goals" tools helps investors develop financial strategies through interactive financial planning services provided by DirectAdvice.com. BuyandHold features three weekly highlights with content provided by Direct Advice, a "Q&A" section, a "Tip of the Week" article, and "The Prudent Planner." Through an affiliated broker, BuyandHold provides online broker services, charging $2.99 for a trade.

Back to TOC